Numerical Restoration of the 2024 Dike-break Flood Process at Tuanzhou Township alongside the Dongting Lake

HU De-chao, WANG Min, MAO Bing, YUAN Yuan, DENG Chun-yan, ZHU Yong-hui

Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute ›› 2024, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (12) : 180-188.

PDF(11370 KB)
PDF(11370 KB)
Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute ›› 2024, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (12) : 180-188. DOI: 10.11988/ckyyb.20240744
Special Column of Water-Related Disaster Prevention and Management

Numerical Restoration of the 2024 Dike-break Flood Process at Tuanzhou Township alongside the Dongting Lake

Author information +
History +

Abstract

A two-dimensional (2D) hydrodynamic model is developed to investigate the dike-break flood at Tuanzhou township alongside the Dongting Lake on July 5, 2024. Integrating both lake and township into a single model, we comprehensively reconstruct the dike-break flood, capturing macroscopic flood processes and detailed flow structures. The model also assesses the flood risk associated with a potential failure of the Qianlianghu-Tuanzhou dike. The model accurately determines when the water levels inside and outside the breach reach equilibrium. It provides precise historical data on breach discharge, water levels inside and outside the breach, flood storage volume, and inundated areas in Tuanzhou township over time. Additionally, the model replicates the water surface scarp around the breach, explaining why water levels near the breach are lower than those in the downstream lake area. The water level and flow velocity distributions around the breach are plotted and analyzed. Moreover, the characteristics of concave water surface outside the breach and the convex water surface inside the breach, together with the water-level gradients are also quantitatively examined. Comparison with field data reveals that the model’s water level error is generally below 10 cm during the dike-break flood (except for the initial breach stage), and drops to less than 5 cm once equilibrium is reached. The discharge error is typically under 5%, with peak discharge error at only 2.5%. The model’s water conservation error is 0.6%, and the discrepancy in maximum flood volume between the model and hydrological department’s results obtained from flood volume versus water level curve is 6.8%. Based on the dike-break flood reconstruction, we design three breaches along the Qianlianghu-Tuanzhou dike and simulate dike-break floods with the existing breach at Tuanzhou township under both blocked and unblocked scenarios. We further quantitatively assess flood risks related to potential dike failures by analyzing the flow field, discharge processes, flood storage, and inundated areas. The findings offer technical support for flood risk assessment and levee protection. The systematic method for simulating real dike-break floods in this study includes integrated modeling of rivers/lakes and townships, detailed township modeling, and iterative calculations to determine breach topography over time. These methods enable accurate simulations of dike-break floods and can serve as a reference for similar studies on dike-break floods.

Key words

Dongting Lake / Tuanzhou township / dike-break flood / two-dimensional hydrodynamic model / exact modeling of townships / integrated simulation of river, lake and townships

Cite this article

Download Citations
HU De-chao , WANG Min , MAO Bing , et al . Numerical Restoration of the 2024 Dike-break Flood Process at Tuanzhou Township alongside the Dongting Lake[J]. Journal of Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute. 2024, 41(12): 180-188 https://doi.org/10.11988/ckyyb.20240744

References

[1]
王超, 张馨月, 罗兴, 等. 团洲垸决口水文应急分析简报(第2-5期)[R]. 武汉: 长江水利委员会水文局, 2024.
(WANG Chao, ZHANG Xin-yue, LUO Xing, et al. Brief Report on the Emergent Hydrologic Analysis of Tuanzhou Dike Breach[R]. Wuhan: Bureau of Hydrology of Changjiang Water Resources Commission, 2024.) (in Chinese)
[2]
黄启有, 吴艳红. 钱粮湖垸洪水风险图编制成果报告[R]. 长沙: 中南勘测设计研究院有限公司, 2015.
(HUANG Qi-you, WU Yan-hong. Achievements Report on the Compiling of Flood Risk Map for Qianlianghu Township[R]. Changsha: Power China Zhongnan Engineering Corporation Limited, 2015.) (in Chinese)
[3]
YUM H, WEI H Y, LIANG Y J, et al. Investigation of Non-cohesive Levee Breach by Overtopping Flow[J]. Journal of Hydrodynamics, 2013, 25(4): 572-579.
[4]
HU D, ZHONG D, ZHANG H, et al. Prediction-Correction Method for Parallelizing Implicit 2D Hydrodynamic Models. I: Scheme[J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2015, 142(1), 04015014.
[5]
HU D, ZHONG D, ZHU Y, et al. Prediction-Correction Method for Parallelizing Implicit 2D Hydrodynamic Models. II: Application[J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2015, 142(1):06015008.
[6]
胡德超. 大时空河流数值模拟理论[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2023.
(HU De-chao. Theory of Large Spatial-temporal Scale Numerical Simulation of Rivers[M]. Beijing: Science Press, 2023.) (in Chinese)
[7]
胡德超. 计算河流工程学[M]. 北京: 清华大学出版社, 2024.
(HU De-chao. Computational River Engineering[M]. Beijing: Tsinghua University Press, 2024.) (in Chinese)
[8]
周建银, 姚仕明, 王敏, 等. 土石坝漫顶溃决及洪水演进研究进展[J]. 水科学进展, 2020, 31(2): 287-301.
(ZHOU Jian-yin, YAO Shi-ming, WANG Min, et al. Review on Overtopping Failure and Flood Evolution of Earth-rock Dams[J]. Advances in Water Science, 2020, 31(2): 287-301.) (in Chinese)
[9]
朱勇辉, 周建银. 堤坝漫溃机理、模型及溃决洪水模拟技术与应用[J]. raybet体育在线 院报, 2023, 40(5): 1-8.
Abstract
为提升堤坝溃决险情处置和溃决灾害防御能力,多年来raybet体育在线 河流研究所采用物理模型试验、水槽试验、理论分析、数值模拟等方法研究了堤坝漫溢溃决的机理、模型与模拟技术。其主要成果包括:揭示了堤坝漫溢溃决机理,解析了“溯源陡坎冲刷”在堤坝溃决过程中的作用,提出了溯源陡坎冲刷模式和堤坝漫溢溃决模式;基于物理机制,研发了溯源陡坎冲刷二维数学模型和堤坝漫溢溃决数学模型;发展了适应溃坝水流急变特征的一、二、三维溃坝洪水运动模拟技术及地形处理方法,并初步探索了溃坝水流的三维流场与动压特性;总结评述了相关领域的研究进展。研究成果成功应用于唐家山、白格等历次堰塞湖溃决险情的应急处置和决策制定,并为今后堤坝(含堰塞坝)溃决险情的科学应对提供了技术参考和经验借鉴。
(ZHU Yong-hui, ZHOU Jian-yin. Embankment Breach Due to Overflowing: Mechanism, Models, Flood Simulation Technologies, and Their Applications[J]. Journal of Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute, 2023, 40(5): 1-8.) (in Chinese)

Over the years, researchers in the River Research Department of the Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute has conducted extensive studies on the mechanism, models, and simulation technologies of embankment breaches due to overflowing. These efforts were aimed at enhancing the ability to respond to embankment breach emergencies and to defend associated disasters. Through the use of physical model tests, flume tests, theoretical analysis, numerical simulation, and other methods, the department has made significant contributions to the field. Specifically, we have uncovered the mechanism of embankment breaches due to overflowing, analyzed the role of “headcut erosion” in the breaching process, and introduced patterns of headcut erosion and phases of embankment breaching due to overflowing. Additionally, we have developed a two-dimensional mathematical model of headcut erosion and a mathematical model of embankment breaching based on the physical mechanism. Furthermore, we have created one-, two-, and three-dimensional flood simulation technologies that are adapted to the characteristics of dam-breaking flow, along with a terrain processing method, and have preliminarily explored the three-dimensional flow field and hydrodynamic pressure characteristics of dam-breaking flow. Last, we made a review on the research progress in related fields and the achievements published in scientific journals. The accomplishments of the department have already proven to be highly effective in emergency response and decision-making, specifically during the Tangjiashan and Baige barrier lake breach emergencies. These achievements provide technical reference and experience for addressing embankment breach (including barrier lake burst) dangers in the future.

致谢

感谢长江水利委员会水文局提供溃口断面地形及水文观测资料,感谢raybet体育在线 空间信息技术应用研究所提供湖区民垸高精度DEM地形数据。

PDF(11370 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

Sections
Recommended

/

Baidu
map