Water Level Variation Monitoring in East Lake, Wuhan Based on Satellite Altimetry

LIU Huo-sheng, WANG Hai-hong, YU Qian-hui, LU Liang, QIN Peng-cheng, LIU Yi-bing

Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute ›› 2025, Vol. 42 ›› Issue (6) : 36-43.

PDF(7484 KB)
PDF(7484 KB)
Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute ›› 2025, Vol. 42 ›› Issue (6) : 36-43. DOI: 10.11988/ckyyb.20240857
Water Resources

Water Level Variation Monitoring in East Lake, Wuhan Based on Satellite Altimetry

Author information +
History +

Abstract

[Objectives] Satellite altimetry has become a crucial method for monitoring lake water levels, yet significant challenges remain in its application to small lakes, particularly in complex urban environments. Currently, limited studies explore the effectiveness of satellite altimetry for monitoring variations of urban lake water levels. Using East Lake in Wuhan as a case study, this study evaluates the quality of Jason-3 satellite altimetry data, aiming to validate the capability of satellite altimetry in monitoring urban lake water level variations. [Methods] Based on the Jason-3 Sensor Geophysical Data Record (SGDR) products from 2017 to 2022, this study used two key parameters—pulse peakiness and waveform width—to first analyze the altimetry waveform characteristics of East Lake. In addition to the original range observations and ICE-retracked ranges provided by SGDR products, this study applied the Offset Center of Gravity (OCOG) and threshold methods for waveform retracking. Among them, the threshold retracking method selected eight threshold levels ranging from 20% to 90% (in 10% increments) to analyze the retracking performance under different thresholds. A robust coarse elimination strategy based on the Median Absolute Deviation (MAD) was employed to eliminate outliers from the water level observation data, followed by the calculation of periodic average water levels to construct the lake water level time series. To evaluate the quality of water level data by different methods, the range and standard deviation of water levels in each period, as well as the number of invalid periods, were statistically analyzed. Additionally, the accuracy of the results using different methods was verified using the measured data from hydrological stations. Finally, meteorological data (precipitation, evaporation) and a water balance model were integrated to quantify the contributions of natural and anthropogenic factors to East Lake’s water level variations. [Results] (1) Statistical analysis of pulse peakiness and waveform width from the lake surface altimetry echoes revealed that approximately 50% of East Lake’s waveforms exhibited specular reflections with distinct sharp peaks, while about 30% displayed complex shapes containing two or more peaks. (2) The results of accuracy validation using the on-site measured data of water levels showed that the 50% threshold retracking method achieved optimal performance, with a root mean square error (RMSE) of 0.108 m and a correlation coefficient of 0.87. (3) Based on the 50% threshold retracking method, and using Jason-3 data, the water level time series of East Lake from September 2017 to February 2022 was established. The results demonstrated that the lake water level remained stable around 19.5 m during this period, with annual fluctuations <0.5 m, monthly variations <0.2 m, and no pronounced seasonal pattern. Although precipitation was the primary water source, water levels showed extremely low correlation with precipitation (R=0.007), and weak negative correlation with evaporation (R=-0.44). According to the analysis of water balance, artificial regulation played a key role in the water level variations of East Lake. [Conclusions] (1) Jason-3 satellite altimetry data can effectively monitor urban lake water level variations, but requires careful data processing, including waveform retracking and outlier elimination. (2) Despite complex waveforms over urban lakes, retracking methods significantly improve altimetry accuracy. Compared with waveform retracking methods such as OCOG, ICE, and threshold method, the 50% threshold method is more suitable for urban lakes.

Key words

water level monitoring / satellite altimetry / urban lake / waveform retracking / East Lake in Wuhan

Cite this article

Download Citations
LIU Huo-sheng , WANG Hai-hong , YU Qian-hui , et al . Water Level Variation Monitoring in East Lake, Wuhan Based on Satellite Altimetry[J]. Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute. 2025, 42(6): 36-43 https://doi.org/10.11988/ckyyb.20240857

References

[1]
彭军, 桂梓玲, 岳克栋, 等. 大型城市浅水湖泊水环境综合治理: 以武汉市东湖为例[J]. 人民长江, 2023, 54(12): 24-33.
(PENG Jun, GUI Zi-ling, YUE Ke-dong, et al. Comprehensive Water Environment Treatment of Large Shallow Urban Lake: Case of East Lake in Wuhan City[J]. Yangtze River, 2023, 54(12): 24-33. (in Chinese))
[2]
方正, 王渲. 对武汉内涝及湖泊调蓄功能的探讨[J]. 中国农村水利水电, 2017(6):101-104,110.
Abstract
武汉市湖泊众多,充分发挥湖泊调蓄调洪潜力是预防内涝的有效措施。2016 年 7 月初,武汉南湖及汤逊湖片区渍水严重,这既是极端天气及自然条件直接造成灾害,也是城市建设间接带来的后果。结合实际降雨、排水资料对南湖水位变化及东沙湖水系调蓄能力进行估算,验证了东湖的调蓄潜力,从而提出挖掘湖泊调蓄能力的建议: 一方面应重视湖泊水系的生态保护,加强对河道、湖泊水体清淤疏浚; 另一方面,应将城区湖泊群作为一个巨大的“海绵”体,通过多湖连通及优化调度,充分发挥湖泊调蓄功能。
(FANG Zheng, WANG Xuan. A Probe into the Waterlogging and Flood Storage Potential of Lakes in Wuhan City[J]. China Rural Water and Hydropower, 2017(6):101-104,110. (in Chinese))
To realize the flood storage potential of numerous lakes in Wuhan City is an effective measure to prevent waterlogging. In July,2016,serious waterlogging disasters occurred in Nanhu and Tangxunhu Areas,which was a direct consequence of extreme weather and natural disasters,and an indirect consequence of urban construction. Based on the actual rainfall and drainage data,we estimate the water level of Nanhu Lake and the flood storage potential of Dongsha Lake. Then suggestions are given: On the one hand,we should pay attention to the ecological protection of water system,strengthen the dredging of river courses and lakes. On the other hand,urban lakes should be considered as a huge“sponge”body,connected to realize optimal regulation.
[3]
罗慧萍, 曹慧群, 罗平安. 引水调度对东沙湖生态水文要素的影响[J]. raybet体育在线 院报, 2020, 37(12):22-27.
Abstract
为了科学评估引水调度的生态水文效应,以大东湖水网中的东沙湖为典型研究对象,从控制水体富营养化的角度,选取最大流速、平均流速、流速>0.01 m/s的水面比例、水龄、换水率共5个指标作为关键生态水文要素,通过构建的东沙湖水动力模型,模拟得到引水调度前、后共计6种工况下,东沙湖流速、水龄的空间分布情况,统计得到各工况下的关键生态水文要素值。对比结果表明:引水调度后,东沙湖最大流速、平均流速、流速>0.01 m/s水面比例、换水率等生态水文要素均明显增加,水龄明显降低。研究成果表明引水调度能有效影响东沙湖生态水文条件,可为开展湖泊生态调度提供参考依据。
(LUO Hui-ping, CAO Hui-qun, LUO Ping-an. Influence of Water Diversion and Dispatching on the Eco-hydrological Elements of Dongsha Lake[J]. Journal of Changjiang River Scientific Research Institute, 2020, 37(12):22-27. (in Chinese))
[4]
杨柯, 段功豪, 牛瑞卿, 等. 基于多源遥感影像的武汉都市发展区湖泊变迁分析[J]. raybet体育在线 院报, 2016, 33(1): 139-142, 146.
Abstract
城市湖泊作为一种重要的生态和旅游资源,其变迁趋势对城市的发展影响深远。为研究武汉都市发展区湖泊变迁情况,引入2013年6月获取的Landsat 8卫星数据,结合都市发展区1975—2013年近40 a 30多期遥感影像作为数据源,利用NDWI和谱间关系法,结合目视解译的方法提取区域内68个湖泊的时空信息,详细研究湖泊面和湖泊边界线的变化情况,基于GIS的空间分析技术和RS的变化检测的方法建立湖泊变迁专题图,并利用景观学指标分析湖泊变化原因。结果表明研究与武汉市政府水资源统计信息相符,为武汉市湖泊资源的保护和可持续发展提供了即时依据。
(YANG Ke, DUAN Gong-hao, NIU Rui-qing, et al. Analysis of Lake Changes in Wuhan Based on Multi-source Remote Sensing Data[J]. Journal of Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute, 2016, 33(1): 139-142, 146. (in Chinese))
Urban lake is an important ecological and tourism resource. Its variation has profound impact on the city’s development. The variations of lake surface and lake boundary in Wuhan are researched in detail by using NDWI and TM2+TM3&gt; TM4+TM5 method in association with visual interpretation to extract the spatio-temporal information of 68 lakes. The research is based on Landsat 8 satellite data obtained in June 2013 and remote sensing images from 1975 to 2013 in the urban development area in Wuhan. Furthermore, thematic map of lake changes is given by using GIS spatial analysis technology and RS change detection method. The causes of lake changes are analysed through landscape indices. The research result is consistent with the government statistics of water resources in Wuhan city. It is also an instant basis for the protection and sustainable development of lake resources in Wuhan city. <br/><br/>
[5]
姜丽光, 刘俊, 张星星. 基于卫星雷达测高技术的湖库动态监测理论、方法和研究进展[J]. 遥感学报, 2022, 26(1): 104-114.
(JIANG Li-guang, LIU Jun, ZHANG Xing-xing. Monitoring Lakes and Reservoirs Using Satellite Radar Altimetry: Theory, Methods, and Progresses[J]. National Remote Sensing Bulletin, 2022, 26(1): 104-114. (in Chinese))
[6]
李建成, 褚永海, 姜卫平, 等. 利用卫星测高资料监测长江中下游湖泊水位变化[J]. 武汉大学学报(信息科学版), 2007, 32(2): 144-147.
(LI Jian-cheng, CHU Yong-hai, JIANG Wei-ping, et al. Monitoring Level Fluctuation of Lakes in Yangtze River Basin by Altimetry[J]. Geomatics and Information Science of Wuhan University, 2007, 32(2): 144-147. (in Chinese))
[7]
廖静娟, 薛辉, 陈嘉明. 卫星测高数据监测青藏高原湖泊2010—2018年水位变化[J]. 遥感学报, 2020, 24(12):1534-1547.
(LIAO Jing-juan, XUE Hui, CHEN Jia-ming. Monitoring Lake Level Changes on the Tibetan Plateau from 2000 to 2018 Using Satellite Altimetry Data[J]. National Remote Sensing Bulletin, 2020, 24(12): 1534-1547. (in Chinese))
[8]
CHEN J, LIAO J. Monitoring Lake Level Changes in China using Multi-Altimeter Data (2016-2019)[J]. Journal of Hydrology, 2020, 590: 125544.
[9]
袁康, 谭德宝, 文雄飞, 等. 库赛湖水位动态监测及气候要素分析[J]. raybet体育在线 院报, 2022, 39(2): 153-158.
Abstract
湖泊的水位数据作为评价湖泊变化的重要指标,对于研究区域水资源变化和生态环境状况具有重要意义。但绝大多数高原湖泊位于人烟稀少、自然条件恶劣的高海拔地区,往往难以获取基础观测数据。以卫星测高数据和遥感影像数据为基础,获得2008—2018年库赛湖水位和面积数据,并结合气象数据对水位变化原因进行分析。结果表明:库赛湖水位变化先后主要经历了缓慢上涨(2008—2011年)→急剧上涨(2011年)→趋于稳定(2013—2018年) 3个阶段。2008—2011年是湖泊水位的缓慢上升期,气候暖湿化是主要原因;2011年由于上游卓乃湖发生溢流,水位短时间内急剧上涨;2012—2018年,在接收大量来水后库赛湖也发生外溢,与上下游湖泊串联成一体,水位开始趋于稳定。对水位数据和气象特征因子进行相关性分析,可见湖泊水位与气象因子的变化情况具有较好的相关性,初步分析认为区域降水量增加是库赛湖水位上涨的主要原因,而气候变暖引起的冰川融水增加、冻土水分释放可能是次要原因。
(YUAN Kang, TAN De-bao, WEN Xiong-fei, et al. Dynamic Monitoring of Water Level Change in Kusai Lake and Analysis of Climatic Driving Forces[J]. Journal of Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute, 2022, 39(2): 153-158. (in Chinese))
The water level data of lakes, as an important indicator for evaluating changes in lakes, are of great significance for studying regional water resources changes and ecological environment conditions. However, most of the plateau lakes are located at high altitudes where population are sparse and natural conditions are harsh, and it is often difficult to obtain basic observation data. Based on satellite altimetry data and remote sensing image data, we obtained the water level and area data of Kusai Lake from 2008 to 2018, and analyzed the causes of water level change in association with meteorological data. Results manifested that the water level of Kusai Lake had gone through three stages from slow rise (2008-2011) to sharp rise (2011), and then to stabilization (2012-2018). The slow rise in the 2008-2011 stage was mainly triggered by warming and humidification of climate; the sharp rise stage in 2011 was caused by overflow in the upstream of Zhuonai Lake; in the 2012-2018 stage, the water level began to stabilize due to overflow in the Kusai Lake after receiving a large amount of incoming water and hence integrating with the upstream and downstream lakes in series. Correlation analysis of water level data and meteorological characteristic factors showed good correlation between lake level and changes in meteorological factors, and preliminary analysis suggested that the increase in regional precipitation was the main reason for the rise in water level of Kusai Lake, while the increase in glacial meltwater and permafrost moisture release caused by climate warming might be secondary causes.
[10]
孙明智, 刘新, 汪海洪, 等. 多源卫星测高数据监测拉昂错1992年—2020年水位变化[J]. 遥感学报, 2022, 26(1):126-137.
(SUN Ming-zhi, LIU Xin, WANG Hai-hong, et al. Monitoring Lake Level Change in La-ang Co from 1992 to 2020 Using Multi-altimeter Data[J]. National Remote Sensing Bulletin, 2022, 26(1):126-137. (in Chinese))
[11]
WINGHAM DJ, RAPLEY CG, GRIFFITHS H. New techniques in satellite tracking system[C]// Proceedings of IGARSS’86 Symposium, Zurich, 1986: 1339-1344.
[12]
DAVISC H. A Robust Threshold Retracking Algorithm for Measuring Ice-sheet Surface Elevation Change from Satellite Radar Altimeters[J]. IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing, 1997, 35(4): 974-979.
[13]
BAMBERJ L. Ice Sheet Altimeter Processing Scheme[J]. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 1994, 15(4): 925-938.
[14]
黄征凯, 汪海洪, 温志强, 等. 基于波形净化技术的内陆湖泊波形重跟踪算法[J]. raybet体育在线 院报, 2021, 38(2): 149-154.
Abstract
卫星测高已经发展为成熟的海洋观测技术,然而在内陆水域的观测精度仍有待提高,其关键在于消除雷达回波中“陆地污染”效应的影响。在近海波形净化技术的基础上,针对内陆水域特点,提出了改进的波形净化技术,用于剔除回波中“陆地污染”导致的异常波峰。在净化波形的基础上,结合优化的重跟踪算法进行波形重跟踪改正,达到提高内陆水域测高观测精度的目的。利用青藏高原中的多个湖泊的水文站数据进行精度检验,结果显示利用波形净化技术消除异常波峰后的波形进行重跟踪改正,平均精度可达到15.8 cm,相较ICE-1算法和阈值法的精度分别提高了14%和27%,表明本算法可有效探测并消除雷达回波的异常峰值,有效提高内陆水域的测高数据观测精度。
(HUANG Zheng-kai, WANG Hai-hong, WEN Zhi-qiang, et al. Waveform Retracking Algorithm for Inland Lake Based on Waveform Decontamination Technology[J]. Journal of Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute, 2021, 38(2): 149-154. (in Chinese))
Satellite altimetry has developed into a mature marine observation technique. But the precision of observation in inland waters needs to be improved, the key of which is to eliminate the effects of land pollution in radar echo. On the basis of the coastal waveform decontamination technology, we propose an improved waveform retracking algorithm for the characteristics of inland waters to eliminate the abnormal peaks caused by land pollution in altimeter waveform. Subsequently, the decontaminated waveform is used for retracking correction to improve the precision of satellite altimetry in inland waters. The measured water level data of several lakes in Qinghai-Tibet Plateau is used for precision testing. The experimental results show that the waveform decontamination technology can eliminate the abnormal peaks in the offshore area, then retrackers are used for the corrected waveform, and the average precision reaches 15.8 centimeter, which is 14% and 27% higher than the accuracy of ICE-1 algorithm and thresholoding method. The results demonstrate that the algorithm can effectively detect and eliminate the abnormal peak of radar waveform and improve the observation accuracy of altimetry data in inland waters.
[15]
HUANG Q, LONG D, DU M, et al. An Improved Approach to Monitoring Brahmaputra River Water Levels Using Retracked Altimetry Data[J]. Remote Sensing of Environment, 2018, 211: 112-128.
[16]
高贤文, 金涛勇, 李建成. 兼顾内陆水体水位时空变化特性的合成孔径雷达波形重跟踪算法[J]. 测绘学报, 2024, 53(2): 217-230.
Abstract
合成孔径雷达(SAR)测高技术已被广泛运用于内陆水位监测中,但内陆水域回波复杂,需要波形重跟踪精化才能获取有效水位。内陆水域SAR高度计回波通常包含多个子波形,重跟踪的主要思路是寻找最优子波形,在特定条件下可以获得较合理水位,但在复杂水域或小水体中容易出现最优子波形筛选错误导致水位异常。传统最优子波形筛选主要是基于沿轨或外部数据约束下进行,而本文提出一种不使用外部数据、兼顾了内陆水体水位时间变化连续且空间变化平稳特性的重跟踪算法SaTCoM,首先对波形进行插值平滑,有效提高子波形识别准确度;然后对所有周期沿轨子波形水位集合进行时间向滤波得到参考水位序列;最后将沿轨子波形水位划分为若干区间并将子波形水位“放入”最近区间,在参考水位波动约束下,根据表征沿轨水位空间稳态特性的指标函数,选择最优水位区间子波形水位计算最终水位。选择我国区域68个大中小型水体的水文站实测数据作为验证,对其附近的哨兵-3A/3B/6A卫星SAR回波数据,分别使用SaTCoM算法、OCOG、ICE1、阈值法和MWaPP+算法重跟踪后进行了比较。结果表明,SaTCoM算法所得内陆水体水位与实测数据不符值RMSE为0.34 m,相对RMSE为7.8%,相关性为0.95,在大部分内陆水体中均表现优异,较其他算法有很大优势,在中小水体中尤为明显,同时分析表明时空约束下的SaTCoM算法仍可以有效捕捉水体水位的快速变化。由此表明,本文算法SaTCoM可较好地解决小水体有效水位获取的困难,能够较大地拓展内陆测高数据的应用。
(GAO Xian-wen, JIN Tao-yong, LI Jian-cheng. An Improved Retracker Considering Spatial and Temporal Characteristics of Inland Water Level Changes for SAR Altimetry[J]. Acta Geodaetica et Cartographica Sinica, 2024, 53(2): 217-230. (in Chinese))
Synthetic aperture radar (SAR) altimetry has been widely used in inland water monitoring, but the echoes from inland waters are complex and need to be retracked to retrieve effective water levels. The SAR waveforms from inland waters usually contain multiple sub-waveforms, The main idea of retracking is to find the optimal sub-waveform. A reasonable water level may be obtained under specific conditions, but the wrong sub-waveform is likely to be picked in complex waters or small water bodies, which leads to abnormal water levels. To solve this problem, we proposed a spatial and temporal constrained multi-subwaveform (SaTCoM) retarcker considering time continuity and spatial stability of inland water level changes,which is different from traditional methods that finding the optimal sub-waveform by along-track or external data. Firstly, to find the sub-waveform reflected from water bodies effectively, SaTCoM interpolates and smooths the waveform. Secondly, the reference water level is obtained by filtering the sub-waveform level point clouds from all cycles in the time direction. Then, the along-track sub-waveform water levels are divided into several intervals and all along-track water levels are put into the nearest interval. Under the constraints of the maximum fluctuation from the reference water level, the indicator function characterizing the along-track spatial stability of the water level is used, which can guide the selection of the optimal water level intervals by maximum.<br>In this paper, we selected 68 hydrological stations with situ level measurements of large, medium, and small water bodies in China as validation, the nearby Sentinel-3A/3B/6A satellite SAR waveforms data were used for five retrackers:SaTCoM, OCOG, ICE1, threshold, and MWaPP+. The results show that the mean RMSE of the inland water level obtained by using SaTCoM is 0.34 m, the relative RMSE is 7.8%, and the correlation with the situ level is 0.95, SaTCoM also performs excellently in most inland water surface and has an absolute advantage over the other retrackers, especially in small and medium-sized water bodies. At the same time, the analysis showed that the SaTCoM can still effectively capture the rapid water level changing signals under spatiotemporal constraints, so it indicates that the proposed retracker SaTCoM can effectively solve the difficulty of retrieving effective water levels in small water bodies, SaTCoM greatly expands the application of inland altimetry data.
[17]
SULISTIOADIY B, TSENG K H, SHUM C K, et al. Satellite Radar Altimetry for Monitoring Small Rivers and Lakes in Indonesia[J]. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 2015, 19(1): 341-359.
[18]
杨兴超, 郭斌, 邢文雪, 等. Sentinel-3测高数据在湖库区域的波形重跟踪方法: 以东平湖和峡山水库为例[J]. 地球物理学报, 2023, 66(3): 986-996.
(YANG Xing-chao, GUO Bin, XING Wen-xue, et al. Waveform Retracking Method of Sentinel-3 Altimetry Data in Lake and Reservoir Areas—Taking Dongping Lake and Xiashan Reservoir as Examples[J]. Chinese Journal of Geophysics, 2023, 66(3): 986-996. (in Chinese))
[19]
MA S, LIAO J, JING R, et al. A Dataset of Lake Level Changes in China between 2002 and 2023 Using Multi-altimeter Data[J]. Big Earth Data, 2024, 8(1): 166-188.
[20]
武汉市水务局. 2020年武汉市水资源公报[EB/OL].(2021-04-13)[2024-07-10].
Wuhan Municipal Water Authority. Wuhan Water Resources Bulletin 2020[EB/OL].(2021-04-13)[2024-07-10]. (in Chinese)
PDF(7484 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

Sections
Recommended

/

Baidu
map